By Surendar Kumar ·

How to Report (and Remove) a Fake Google Review

You open your Business Profile and there it is. One star. A name you've never seen. A complaint about something that never happened, or no text at all.

It stings, especially for a small business where every star counts. And the first instinct is to reply with something angry, or to find someone who "knows a guy at Google."

Don't do either. There's a proper process, it's free, and you should know exactly what it can and can't do. Everything below comes from Google's own help pages, so you're not relying on rumours from Facebook groups.

First, be honest: is it actually fake?

Before you report anything, check:

  • Your records. Search your orders, bookings, WhatsApp chats and invoices for the name, the date or the details mentioned.
  • The reviewer's profile. Tap their name. Do they have other reviews? Are they all one-star reviews for businesses in your area? A strange pattern is worth noting.
  • The timing. Did several negative reviews arrive on the same day, with no matching orders?
  • The details. Does the review describe a product you don't sell, a branch you don't have, or staff you don't employ?

Sometimes the "fake" review turns out to be a real customer who used a nickname, or ordered under a family member's name. If that's the case, reply to it properly instead. Here's my workflow for replying to Google reviews with ChatGPT.

What Google will remove (and what it won't)

Google's help page on reporting inappropriate reviews is very clear: you can report any review, but only reviews that break Google's policies are eligible for removal. It also says don't report a review just because you disagree with it, and that Google doesn't get involved in conflicts between businesses and customers.

So "the customer is wrong about our delivery time" won't get a review removed. A policy violation will. Under Google's Maps user-generated content policy, these are the main ones that apply to fake or unfair reviews:

  • Fake engagement: content not based on a real experience, reviews paid for, or content posted from multiple accounts by one person.
  • Competitors: posting content on a competitor's business to damage its reputation.
  • Conflict of interest: for example, reviews from current or former employees.
  • Harassment and personal information: threats, doxxing, or posting someone's private details without consent.
  • Offensive content: this includes unsubstantiated allegations of unethical behavior or criminal wrongdoing.
  • Hate speech, profanity used to offend, and spam or repetitive content.

When you report, pick the reason that matches what's really wrong. "Not a real customer" and "competitor attack" are fake engagement problems. Abuse aimed at a staff member is harassment.

How to report a fake Google review, step by step

Option 1: From your Business Profile

  1. Go to your Business Profile.
  2. Select Read reviews.
  3. Next to the review, select Report.
  4. Choose the reason, for example "Spam."
  5. Select Send report.

Option 2: From the Reviews Management Tool

Google's Reviews Management Tool is the better option, because it also shows you the status of each report.

  1. Open the Reviews Management Tool and confirm the email address linked to your Business Profile.
  2. Select your business.
  3. Choose Report a new review for removal.
  4. Select Report next to the review, choose the reason and submit.

Google says evaluation typically takes several days. In the tool, you'll see one of these statuses:

  • Decision pending: flagged, not evaluated yet.
  • Report reviewed, no policy violation: Google checked and decided to keep it.
  • Escalated, check your email for updates: your appeal is being looked at.

Option 3: Report the reviewer's profile

If one account is leaving fake reviews across lots of businesses, you can report the profile itself. In the Google Maps app, open your business reviews, tap the reviewer's name, then tap More > Report in their profile.

If Google says "no policy violation": the one-time appeal

You get one appeal per review, so make it count. From the Reviews Management Tool:

  1. Choose the option to check the status of reviews you reported earlier.
  2. Select Appeal eligible reviews.
  3. Pick the review (you can select up to 10 at once).
  4. Fill in the form and submit.

Google emails you the result. If the review breaks the policy, it's removed. If not, it stays.

My tip for the appeal form: be factual and short. "We have no order, booking or message from this name on this date. The reviewer posted one-star reviews on five other bakeries in our area on the same day." That's far stronger than "This is clearly fake and unfair!!!"

If someone is demanding money to remove reviews

This is a growing scam, and Google now has a specific process for it. Its page on review extortion scams describes a sudden rush of one- and two-star reviews, followed by someone demanding money, goods or services to remove them. Often the demand comes on WhatsApp, Telegram or email.

Google's advice:

  • Don't engage with or pay them. Paying doesn't guarantee removal and can encourage more attempts.
  • Don't try to settle it yourself by offering money or services.
  • Collect evidence straight away: screenshots of every message and demand, dates, and links to the reviews.
  • Submit everything through Google's merchant extortion report form (linked from that help page).

When it's a legal matter

If a review makes serious false claims that could be a legal issue, such as defamation, Google has a separate Report Content for Legal Reasons page. For anything that serious, talk to a lawyer in your country before you file. I'm a marketer, not a lawyer, and this isn't legal advice.

How to reply to a fake review while you wait

Removal can take days, and sometimes the review stays. Meanwhile, new customers are reading it. A short, calm reply protects you better than silence or an argument.

What to do:

  • Stay neutral. Don't accuse them of lying.
  • Say you can't find a record of their visit or order.
  • Invite them to contact you directly so you can look into it.
  • Never share anyone's personal details, even if you think you know who it is.

English example:

Hi, we take every review seriously, but we couldn't find any order or visit matching your name or the details here. Please message us on the number on our profile so we can look into it properly.

Roman Urdu example:

Assalam o Alaikum, hum har review ko seriously lete hain, lekin humein aap ke naam ya in details se mutabiq koi order ya visit nahi mila. Meharbani kar ke hamare profile par diye gaye number par rabta karein taake hum is ko theek se dekh sakein.

A customer reading that reply sees a calm business owner. A customer reading an angry reply sees a business that fights with people.

Not every bad review is fake, of course. For the genuine ones, like a late delivery or a rude staff member, here are 12 example replies to negative Google reviews you can adapt.

What not to do

  • Don't post fake positive reviews to "balance it out." That breaks the same policy, and Google's Business Profile restrictions can include blocking new reviews and showing a warning to customers that fake reviews were removed.
  • Don't ask a crowd of friends to flag it. It won't change what the policy says, and coordinated activity is the last thing you want attached to your business.
  • Don't pay anyone who promises guaranteed removal. Nobody outside Google can promise that.

The best long-term defense

One fake review on a profile with 12 reviews is a disaster. The same review on a profile with 300 genuine ones barely matters.

So keep real reviews coming in every week. Here's how to get more Google reviews without breaking Google's rules, and some ready-made WhatsApp messages to ask customers for reviews in English and Roman Urdu.

If you're dealing with lots of reviews across locations, Reviewtor, the review management tool I'm building, puts all your reviews in one place so new ones (including suspicious ones) don't slip past you, and helps you reply faster.

FAQ

Can Google remove a fake review?

Yes, if it breaks Google's content policies, for example if it isn't based on a real experience, comes from a competitor or is abusive. Google won't remove a review just because you disagree with it.

How long does it take Google to remove a reported review?

Google says review evaluation typically takes several days. You can track the status in the Reviews Management Tool.

What can I do if Google doesn't remove the fake review?

You can submit a one-time appeal through the Reviews Management Tool. If the appeal is rejected too, reply calmly to the review and focus on getting more genuine reviews.

Should I reply to a fake Google review?

Yes, usually. Keep it short and neutral, say you can't find a record of the customer, and invite them to contact you directly. Don't accuse or share personal details.

Keep reading

Want more like this?

Online reputation is one of the modules in the digital marketing course I'm launching soon. Follow me on LinkedIn to hear about it first.

Surendar Kumar is a digital marketing consultant and founder. He started PixelTrackMedia (acquired), is building Reviewtor for online reputation management, and runs All AI Directory and TalkToKrishna. He talks about AI, digital marketing and entrepreneurship.

Find me on LinkedIn · YouTube · X · Instagram · Pinterest